TYPE IX COLLAGEN ANTIBODY AND RELATED USES
1. FIELD OF THE INVENTION
The present invention is directed to antibodies to type IX human collagen and
methods of diagnosing diseases wherein a characteristic of such disease is the abnormal
expression of type IX collagen in relevant body fluids or tissues. More specifically, the present invention is further directed to detecting or monitoring rheumatoid arthritis and other autoimmune diseases wherein the abnormal expression of type IX collagen is
implicated by determining the levels of type IX collagen by way of a type IX collagen
antibody in a patient sample. The present invention is further directed to detecting or
monitoring connective tissue diseases wherein the abnormal expression of type IX collagen is implicated in, for example, chondrosarcoma and endosarcoma. The present
invention is further directed to a reagent kit and antibodies useful in carrying out such
methods.
2. BACKGROUND OF THE INVENTION
Collagen. Collagen is the most abundant component of the extracellular matrix.
The collagen superfamily comprises at least nineteen (19) molecules which are generally
the result of three polypeptide chains containing, in their primary sequence, (-Gly-X-Y-)n
repeats which allow for the formation of triple helical domains (van der Rest et al., 1991, FASEB J. 5:2814-2823). Characterized by their structure and biological function,
specific collagen types arrange within extracellular matrices in precise aggregates,
maintaining a delicate equilibrium in specialized tissues.
The full polypeptide and polynucleotide sequences corresponding to human type IX collagen have been recently reported for each of the molecules comprising the type IX collagen trimer. Mayne, et al, 1993, J. Biol. Chem. 268(13):9381-86; Brewton, et al,
1992, Eur. J. Biochem 205(2):443-9; Brewton, et al, 1991, J. Biol. Chem. 266(8):4752-
57; Zhidkova, et al, 1993, FEBS Lett. 326(l-3):25-28. Type IX collagen is a fibril associated collagen related to types II and XI collagen. Type IX collagen is a
heterotrimer comprised of three different subunits; αl(IX), α2(IX) and α3(IX). The
type IX collagen molecule has three collagenous domains and four non-collagenous
domains.
Diseases And Disorders Associated With Collagen. A number of diseases are
associated with collagen gene expression. In autoimmune disorders, such as rheumatoid arthritis, expression of collagen types IX and XI, as well as collagen type II have been
discovered. In degenerative joint diseases such as osteoarthrosis, collagen expression of
types II and IX have been detected in a model of osteoarthrosis. Lefkoe et al, 1997, J Rheumatol 24(6): 1155-1163. The abnormal expression of type IX collagen have also been observed in other connective tissue diseases which are not "autoimmune" in nature
and which are related to the cartilage. For example, type IX collagen has been detected to
be distinctly localized in cartilaginous tumors in conditions such as enchondroma,
chondrosarcoma, and secondary chondrosarcoma. Kawashima et al, 1993, J Cancer Res
Clin Oncol 120:35-40. Moreover, the irregular deposition of type IX collagen in human
cartilaginous tumors has also been observed.
Methods For Diagnosing Autoimmune Disorders. Current methods of
diagnosing and detecting autoimmune disorders typically rely on the onset of symptoms
which characterize the disorder. For example, current methods for diagnosing
rheumatoid arthritis rely upon the presence or absence of seven criteria. Takagishi and Yamamoto, 1992, Nippon Rinsho 50(3):490-494. More recently, studies have been
performed to diagnose rheumatoid arthritis by measuring the presence of collagen type II in cartilage. Fujii, et al, 1992, Int. Orthop 16(3):272-76. These studies have met with
moderate success. For example, according to Fujii, et al, use of antibodies to type II
collagen in enzyme-linked immunosorbent assays resulted in a 22.7% success rate in
detecting rheumatoid arthritis in a patient population known to have such disorder. Studies wherein certain antibody levels from sera are measured have also shown
moderate correlation with disease. Although type IX collagen, in addition to type II
collagen, may be a relevant tool to diagnose rheumatoid arthritis, the extraction of intact
type IX collagen has been difficult to accomplish to date such that antibodies to type IX collagen have not been reported.
No method to date, except for the observation of rheumatoid arthritis "factors"
and symptoms, has provided a means for consistently detecting rheumatoid arthritis.
General Diagnostic Methods For Detecting Diseases And Disorders. Methods
wherein a monoclonal antibody is utilized to diagnose diseases have been described generally in the relevant art. See e.g., United States Patent No. 5,298,393 and United
States Patent No. 4,628,027. Specific diagnostic methods utilizing antibodies to specific
markers have also been disclosed. For example, the method of diagnosing diseases, such as cancer, utilizing a monoclonal antibody recognizing glutathione S-transferase is
described by United States Patent No. 5,298,393. Likewise, monoclonal antibodies
which purportedly diagnose fibrosis by recognizing connective tissue proteins,
specifically, collagen types I, II, III, IV, and V, are described generally in U.S. Patent No. 4,628,027 ("027 Patent"). The '027 patent, however, does not disclose antibodies
specific to type IX collagen or their application to the diagnosis of disease.
3. SUMMARY OF THE INVENTION
It has been found that type IX collagen varies in its distribution throughout body
tissues as result of various disease states. The present invention provides for various approaches for detecting and measuring the changes in distribution and levels of type IX collagen, thereby, providing for a diagnostic assessment of the pathological stages of
autoimmune disorders and connective tissue disorders associated with type IX collagen.
Such autoimmune diseases include rheumatoid arthritis. Connective tissue disorders in
which abnormal type IX collagen expression is implicated include ocular disorders, chondrodysplasia. chondrosarcoma, secondary chondrosarcoma, and endochondroma.
Methods. The present invention comprises a means of diagnosing
autoimmune disorders or connective tissue disorders such as rheumatoid arthritis and
osteoarthrosis. Specifically, the present invention provides for the detection and
monitoring of the presence and proliferation of type IX collagen or its subunits in tissues
related to rheumatoid arthritis and osteoarthrosis, e.g., cartilage, and connective tissue
disorders related to ocular diseases, chondrodysplasia, chondrosarcoma, secondary
chondrosarcoma and enchondroma. More specifically, the present invention provides for
autoimmune disorders and particularly type IX collagen, subunits, or fragments thereto, by measuring the levels of such collagen in a patient sample, preferably a patient's serum
or synovial fluid.
In one embodiment of the present invention, a method is provided for wherein the presence of type II and/or type XI collagen is measured in addition to type IX collagen, related subunits, and fragments thereto (type IX collagen and subunits, and
fragments thereto are hereinafter defined as "Type IX Collagen"). In another
embodiment of the present invention, patient samples analyzed for the presence of Type
IX Collagen are tissue samples or fluid samples from serum or synovial fluid. Preferably, the method provides for the measurement of Type IX Collagen levels from a serum
sample wherein a comparison is made between the levels of Type IX Collagen in a serum
samples from a patient known or suspected to have an autoimmune disorder and more
particularly rheumatoid arthritis, and the levels of Type IX Collagen in a non-diseased
serum sample. The method provides that higher levels of Type IX Collagen from serum
samples from patients suspected or known to have rheumatoid arthritis to levels in non- diseased serum samples is indicative of the presence of such autoimmune disorder.
Abnormal levels of Type IX Collagen from serum samples of patients suspected or
known to have an autoimmune disorder or connective tissue disorder serve as a
prognostic indicator of such disorder. In addition, the present invention provides for the
measurement of Type IX Collagen levels in synovial fluid samples from patients known
or suspected to have a degenerative joint disease such as osteoarthrosis using similar
markers as described above.
The method of the present invention utilizes an antibody or antigen binding fragment thereof, preferably, a monoclonal antibody, which is reactive with and capable
of specifically detecting human Type IX Collagen. In one embodiment of the present
invention, the antibody is human or humanized. The antibodies of the present invention may be used in standard radioimmunoassays or enzyme-linked immunosorbent assays or
other assays which are known to utilize antibodies for measurement of levels of Type IX
Collagen in a serum sample. The method of utilizing an antibody to measure the levels of
Type IX Collagen allows for a non-invasive diagnosis of rheumatoid arthritis, as well as
other autoimmune disorders wherein the abnormal expression of Type IX Collagen is implicated.
The present invention also provides for the specificity and reliability in detecting
and measuring Type IX Collagen in tissue and body fluids for the diagnostic evaluation
of the presence and stages of disorders, and preferably autoimmune or connective tissue disorders. More preferably, the disorder is rheumatoid arthritis. The present invention
also provides for the pathological testing and diagnosing of the malignant catilaginous
tumors associated with diseases such as enchondroma and chondrosarcoma. For
example, the present invention provides for methods of diagnosing the presence of an
autoimmune disorder, for determining the progress of such autoimmune disease in
patients and for serving as a prognostic indicator of the extent of the disease.
Diagnostic Kit. The present invention is further directed to a kit consisting
of antibodies and reagents. In a preferred embodiment, the diagnostic kit comprises
reagents for measuring Type IX Collagen (type IX collagen, subunits thereof, or the
individual α chains of type IX collagen) existing in body fluids such as serum. In yet
another preferred embodiment, the kit further comprises antibodies to type II and type XI
collagen. In one embodiment of the present invention, the kit comprises immobilized
antibodies or their chimeras which specifically recognize Type IX Collagen and type II collagen and/or type XI collagen.
The antibodies comprising the present invention may be differentially labeled and
are capable of binding to an antigen component. The kit also comprises the reagents
necessary for the detection of the enzyme-labeled antibody. Other reagents which may be necessary may be added, for example, dissolving agents, cleaning agents and reaction
terminators.
In a preferred embodiment of the invention, the kit is packaged and labeled for
example, in a box or container which includes the necessary elements of the kit, and directions and instructions on the use of such diagnostic kit.
Antibodies. The present invention further comprises antibodies or antigen
binding fragments thereof reactive with and specific for Type IX Collagen. Preferably,
the antibody or antigen binding fragment thereof is to human type IX collagen, subunits,
and fragments thereof and is a monoclonal antibody. Such antibodies may be generated, for example, by obtaining a hybridoma that produces a monoclonal antibody specific to
Type IX Collagen by fusing a myeloma cell with antibody-secreting cells of an animal
immunized with human type IX collagen or the epitopes of the α subunits of type IX
human collagen described below, culturing said hybridoma and/or a cell line arising
therefrom, and harvesting the monoclonal antibody specific to human Type IX Collagen.
4. BRIEF DESCRIPTION OF THE DRAWINGS
Figure 1 (FIG. 1) shows the selection of peptides for immunization: Sequences
underlined were chosen for peptides for immunization of rabbits. Sequences in Italic and
underlined were chosen for peptides used for immunization of goats. FIGURE 1A
corresponds to the sequences for the collagen type IX α(l)IX chain. FIGURE IB
corresponds to the sequences for the collagen type IX α(2)IX chain. FIGURE 1C
corresponds to the sequence for the collagen type IX α(3)IX chain.
Figure 2 (FIG. 2) shows a schematic depiction of collagen type IX.
Figure 3 (FIGS. 3A and 3B) show characterization data related to the synthesized peptides.
Figure 4 (FIG. 4) shows SDS-PAGE of recombinant human collagen type IX.
Figure 5 (FIG. 5) depicts immunoblotting of antisera from rabbits against
individual chains of collagen IX.
5. DETAILED DESCRIPTION OF THE INVENTION
Antibodies. The present invention provides for antibodies specific for Type IX
Collagen. Several methods may be employed for obtaining the monoclonal antibodies of
the present invention. For example, a ready source of monoclonal antibodies may be
obtained from fusion of antibody-secreting cells with non-antibody-secreting myeloma
cells resulting in a hybridoma. These hybridomas provide a ready source of monoclonal antibodies.
The hybridoma which produces the monoclonal antibodies of the present
invention, specifically, the monoclonal antibodies recognizing Type IX Collagen may be
produced according to cell fusion techniques as exemplified in publications such as Kohler and Milstein, Nature 256:495-497 (1975) In such technique, animals, for
example, rabbits, monkeys, mice, rats, goats, etc. are immunized with Type IX Collagen (for example, the subunit epitopes at FIG. 1 ) and antibody producing cells from their
spleen, lymph node, etc. are collected and fused with human or animal myeloma cells.
The myeloma cell lines that may be used are described in for example, Monoclonal
Antibodies and T-cell Hybridomas in: J.L. Turk (editor) Research Monographs in Immunology Vol. 3, Elsevier/North Holland Biomedical Press, New York (1981).
Those hybridomas secreting monoclonal antibodies of the present invention may
then be selected from the colonies of hybridomas produced by cell fusion. Selection of
the desired hybridomas can be conducted by techniques such as enzyme- linked- immunosorbent assay (ELISA) or a radioimmnoassay, as described in R. Kennet et al.
Monoclonal Antibodies, hybridomas; a new dimension in biological analyses, pp. 376-
384, Plenum Press, New York (1980), to confirm that the monoclonal antibodies
produced by the hybridomas result in an antigen-antibody reaction with Type IX
Collagen. The hybridomas secreting the desired monoclonal antibody are cloned into individual antibody-producing cell lines by methods described in, for example, G.J.
Hammerling et al, thereby, producing a ready source of monoclonal antibodies specific
for Type IX Collagen.
Methods for obtaining human or humanized antibodies may also be used to obtain antibodies of the present invention. Such methods are described in, for example, EP
765172, EP 671951, US 4,574,116, US 4,350,683, US 5,593,822, US 5,422,245, US
4,713,351, EP 589877, US 5,565,332, and EP 616640.
The detection and monitoring of diseases associated with Type DC collagen expression. Although not as prevalent as type II collagen, type IX collagen, as well as
type XI collagen have been shown to be expressed in the cartilage of patients having
certain autoimmune disorders, such as rheumatoid arthritis. To the extent that
rheumatoid arthritis and/or osteoarthrosis can be detected only in an undefined segment
of the relevant patient population by measuring levels of type II collagen, a detection and/or monitoring protocol which measures not only the presence of type II collagen, but
also type IX and/or type XI collagen may be useful. The presence of such collagens may
be detected by use of the antibodies of the present invention. For example, samples from
synovial fluid or serum may be withdrawn from patients suspected of having rheumatoid
arthritis or osteoarthrosis and subjected to immunoassays with antibodies, and preferentially monoclonal antibodies, against Type IX Collagen, as well types II and/or
XI collagen. The presence of abnormal levels of type IX collagen compared to normal
would be a basis for detecting and monitoring the pathological conditions of rheumatoid
arthritis and/or osteoarthrosis. The use of antibodies of the present invention provides for an early and accurate diagnosis of cartilage related autoimmune diseases such as
rheumatoid arthritis or other connective tissue disorders.
The antibodies of the present invention may also be used to diagnose pathological
conditions of autoimmune diseases or connective tissue disorders by histological
diagnosis of tissue samples wherein the antibodies against Type IX Collagen detect changes in distribution of Type IX Collagen. For example, it has been demonstrated that
human cartilaginous tumors associated with disorders such as enchondroma and
chondrosarcoma, the uneven distribution of type IX collagen has been detected. Use of
the antibodies specific for Type IX Collagen would allow for detecting changes in type IX collagen distribution in applicable cartilage tissue which could serve as an indicator of
the presence or progressive stage of applicable autoimmune diseases such as rheumatoid
arthritis. Moreover, use of the antibodies or antigen binding fragments of the present
invention may allow for the pathological testing of malignant cartilaginous tumors associated with enchondroma, chondrosarcoma, and other related diseases.
Detection of Type IX Collagen levels may be obtained through immunoassay
methods, for example, enzyme-linked immunosorbent assay (ELISA), sandwich ELISA,
radioimmunoassay or any other known assays which utilize an antibody to detect the presence of a protein marker. The ELISA, sandwhich ELISA and radioimmunoassay
methods are preferred and may, with the monoclonal antibodies of the present invention
be used to detect specifically the presence of Type IX Collagen. In a preferred method of
the invention, serum samples are obtained first from patients suspected or known to have
an autoimmune disorder; wherein said disorder is preferably rheumatoid arthritis. The
serum sample is measured for levels of Type IX Collagen through immunoassay, and
compared with the amount of Type IX Collagen levels in a second non-diseased serum
sample to determine presence or progression of a disorder. The same methods may be
used to monitor the disorder. For example, a first serum sample measured for levels of
Type IX Collagen is obtained from a patient known to have, for example, rheumatoid
arthritis, and compared to levels of Type IX Collagen in samples taken subsequent to the
first samples. Such method allows for monitoring the progression of the rheumatoid arthritis.
In the present invention, enzyme-linked immunosorbent assay (ELISA) can be
used to measure levels of Type IX Collagen present in serum samples. For example,
monoclonal antibodies against Type IX Collagen are conjugated to an appropriate enzyme such as horseradish peroxidase, protein ferritin, enzyme alkaline phosphatase, β-
D-galactosidase etc. These enzyme-linked antibody preparations are mixed with the
serum samples which contain unknown amounts of Type IX Collagen. Since the
antibody is specific for Type IX Collagen, antigen-antibody binding occurs after an incubation period, and transferred to a microtiter plate which have been precoated with
Type IX Collagen. Unbound antibodies bind to the antigen absorbed to the walls of the microtiter wells. The initial antigen-antibody complexes are washed out of the wells of
the microtiter plate leaving the enzyme-linked antibodies complexed to the antigen
coating the walls. A substrate is added and enzymatic activity is measured. The method of enzyme-linked immunosorbent assay (ELISA) is described in R. Kennet et al, supra.
In the present invention, sandwich ELISA techniques may also be used to
measure levels of autoantibodies to type IX collagen. More particularly, in autoimmune
diseases such as rheumatoid arthritis wherein a characteristic of the disease is the
production of autoantibodies, use of the monoclonal antibody or antigen binding
fragments thereof reactive with Type IX Collagen, autoantibodies to Type IX Collagen
may be detected using sandwich ELISA techniques. For example, the monoclonal
antibody of the present invention or antigen-binding fragment thereof is bound to a solid
phase support, as the first component of a "sandwich-type" assay. A sample containing
human type IX collagen is added to said component wherein an antigen-antibody complex is formed. A second sample of synovial fluid or serum, for example, is contacted to the bound type IX collagen antigen wherein an autoantibody binds to the
type IX collagen antigen. A third antibody conjugated with a labeled enzyme is added
which allows for the detection of the autoantibody specific for type IX collagen. The
techniques of sandwich ELISA are described in, for example, Ausubel et al, Current Protocol of Molecular Biology, Volume 2, pp. 11.2.4-1 1.2.7, Wiley Interscience,
publishers. The detection of such autoantibodies to Type IX Collagen may serve as a prognostic marker for rheumatoid arthritis.
Radioimmunassay may also be used to measure levels of Type IX Collagen. For
example, Type IX Collagen is radioactively labeled and mixed with monoclonal antibodies specific for Type IX Collagen and a serum sample containing an unknown
amount of unlabeled Type IX Collagen. Binding competition between the labeled and
unlabeled Type IX Collagen with the monoclonal antibody occurs. By measuring the
amount of radioactivity of the reaction mixmre, the amount of Type IX Collagen present in the sample can be quantitatively determined. The method of radioimmunoassay is
described further in publications such as US Patent Nos. 4,438,209 and 4,591,573.
The antibodies against Type IX Collagen can be used in combination with
antibodies to detect the related type II and/or type XI collagens in order to better canvas a
patient population.
Kits. The present invention also involves reagents and kits comprising such reagent for measuring Type IX Collagen in fluid samples. The diagnostic kit of the invention contains reagents for measuring levels of Type IX Collagen in serum samples.
This reagent kit comprises an antibody, and preferably a monoclonal antibody, which
specifically detects Type IX Collagen bound to a support, and a second antibody, again preferably a monoclonal antibody, which is specific to Type IX Collagen that binds to a
different epitope of the Type IX Collagen molecule. The second is enzyme-labeled. In
addition, the reagent kit of the present invention comprises reagents for detecting the
enzyme-labeled monoclonal antibody. The reagent kit employs immunological methods
in measuring Type IX Collagen in the serum sample, thus allowing for the detection and
monitoring of cartilage related autoimmune diseases such as rheumatoid arthritis. The kit is packaged and labeled, for example, in box or container which includes the necessary
elements of the kit, and directions and instructions on the use of such diagnostic kit.
6. EXAMPLES
Preparation of Antibodies Against Human Collagen IX
Design of Peptides for Immunization. The sensitivity of type IX collagen to
proteinase and its cross-linking to type II collagen make the extraction of intact type IX
collagen from cartilage extremely difficult. Therefore, peptide antibodies were designed and then made. As the collagen domain is a poor immunogen, peptides chosen for
immunization were from non-collagen domains. For αl(IX), one sequence was selected
from NC4 domain and another was chosen from NC2 domain. For α2(IX), two peptides
were chosen from NC2 domain with four amino acid residual overlap. For α3(IX) chain,
one was from NC2 and another from the interface between NC2 and Col 2 domain were
selected. The locations of peptides in the collagen IX are shown in FIG. 1. As set forth
at FIG. 2, depicting a schematic representation of collagen type IX, there is no GAG in the NC3 domain of α2(IX) chains.
Peptides Synthesis, Immunization and Sera Collection. Peptides were synthesized
based on the sequences depicted at FIG. 1A-1C using known techniques. One cysteine residue was added in the less immunogenic end of the peptides for conjugating peptides
to the carrier. The peptides were purified by reverse phase C8 column operated by HPLC.
The identity of the peptide was confirmed by Mass Spectrum. One example is shown in
FIG. 3 A and 3B. To obtain the desired immunogenic response to the small peptide, the
peptide was conjugated to a carrier protein. In this example, the carrier used was ovalbumin, one of most commonly used carrier protein with well characterized T-cell determinants.
After pre-bleeding, animals were injected with peptide-carrier conjugates mixed
with Complete Freund's Adjuvant. The animals then were injected every two weeks and
test-bleeds were performed for monitoring the antibody titers. Production bleeds were performed after three boosts.
Antibody Titer and Specificity. Peptide-carrier conjugates were used to test the
antibody titer by ELISA with HRP conjugated second antibodies. The results are
expressed by the reciprocal of the serum dilution that results in an OD492nm of 0.200, as set forth at Table 1, below.
Table 1 Antibody titer of antisera against individual chain of human collagen IX from Rabbits α Chain Rabbits Pre-bleed Prod. Bleed αl(IX) 42176 <50 >200,000 αl(IX) 42175 <50 28,400 α2(IX) 42177 <50 >200,000 cc2(IX) 42178 <50 104,500 α3(IX) 42174 <50 31,500 α3(IX) 42173 <50 88,800
The specificity of the antisera were tested by immunoblotting. Heterotrimer of recombinant human collagen type IX and homotrimer of each individual chain expressed in baculovirus system were used. Resolution of cell extracts by polyacrylamide gel
electrophoresis is shown in FIG. 4. The results of immunoblotting using enhanced
chemiluminescence are in FIG. 5 and show that all antisera are specific for recombinant
human collagen type IX, as expressed in a baculovirus system. Antisera against each
individual type IX collagen α chain does not cross-react with other type IX collagen α
chains and all the antisera do not show significant cross-reactivity with host insect cell
protein. The specificity for collagen IX in other expression system as well as in cartilage
could be examined in a similar fashion, if it is needed.
All references cited within the body of the instant specification are hereby
incorporated by reference in their entirety. In addition, the publications listed below are
of interest in connection with various aspects of the invention and are incorporated herein
as part of the disclosure: