WO2008090219A1

WO2008090219A1 - Method for derusting metallic surfaces

Info

Publication number: WO2008090219A1
Application number: PCT/EP2008/050893
Authority: WO
Inventors: Christiaan Reinder Wijnia
Original assignee: Purac Biochem Bv
Priority date: 2007-01-25
Filing date: 2008-01-25
Publication date: 2008-07-31
Also published as: EP1950327A1

Abstract

The invention pertains to a method for derusting a metallic surface by bringing the surface in contact with an aqueous solution of a buffer having a pH between 5.1 and 6.5, wherein the buffer comprises lactic acid and the sodium, potassium and/or ammonium salt of lactic acid. A preferred combination is a lactic acid-ammonium lactate buffer.

Description

METHOD FOR DERUSTING METALLIC SURFACES

The invention relates to a novel method for derusting metallic surfaces.

Rust forming on metal surfaces is a common problem in industry. As a result of the formation of rust deposits, pit corrosion occurs inside steel pipes. Pit corrosion can damage, and causes leakage in pipes. Therefore, cooling installations frequently have to shut down and as a direct result, also the plant for intensive inspection. This all is very time consuming and very expensive. It is known to use lactic acid for rust removal, but this product has the disadvantage that when applied during longer periods itself causes corrosion.

Throughout the years many methods have been proposed to tackle these problems. Notwithstanding these many published methods the following problems have not fully been solved. Thus removal of rust in production plant installations often require considerable shut down times, derusting compositions may be environmental hazardous, or such compositions may be expensive. Further, derusting usually is accompanied with damaging the metallic surface. Some of these problems have been solved in WO

2005/033365. This patent application discloses on page 3 the use of solutions of citric acid, or other organic hydroxy acids, for derusting steel parts. In particular citric acid is preferred, optionally in a mixture with a citrate such as ammonium citrate. An ammonium salt of said acid may further be used as buffer for these acid solutions. Such solutions should have a pH between 2.5 and 5 in order to obtain sufficient derusting, and further contain tin sulfate for reducing iron (III) to iron (II) ions. Instead of citric acid also mixtures of lactic acid or tartaric acid in combination with tin sulfate were exemplified. When citric acid is used also the combination citric acid-ammonium citrate-tin sulfate is described. The metal parts are thereby immersed in the derusting solution for about 15 minutes and then rinsed with a basic solution. It was found that this solution is less suitable for plant installations, which cannot be immersed therein but through which the solution must be pumped for a considerable longer time than used in WO 2005/033365. When used in that manner unacceptable damaging of steel pipes and the like may occur. Furthermore, it is disadvantageous that citric acid is a solid, making dosing and dissolving in cooling water difficult, particularly leading to difficulties at effective pH control.

It is therefore an object of the invention to provide a method that is devoid of the above disadvantages and nevertheless is environmental friendly and cheap. To this end the invention pertains to a method for derusting a metallic surface by bringing the surface in contact with an aqueous solution of a buffer having a pH between 5.1 and 6.5, wherein the buffer comprises lactic acid and the sodium, potassium and/or ammonium salt of lactic acid.

Thus according to the present invention it was found that considerable higher pH values can be used for derusting when the organic acid is lactic acid buffered with a sodium, potassium, or an ammonium salt, or a mixture thereof. These higher pH values have the considerable advantage that virtually no decomposition of the metallic surface can occur, whereas derusting properties are still satisfactory. This effect was not obtained when a citric acid-ammonium citrate buffer was used, since this was found to be insufficiently active for effective derusting such surfaces at these higher pH levels. The present invention is of particular importance for removing rust within steel pipes as used in plant installations such as cooling installations. Pit corrosion in such pipes can cause serious damage and leakage of the pipes. Prevention is thus of utmost importance to prevent shut down of the installations and intensive inspection.

In such applications, apart from using citric acid, the use of aqueous lactic acid solutions was common and very effective, however, at the cost of surface damage at the inside of the pipes. Furthermore, the use of lactic acid as such does not prevent bacteria growth.

The above given novel method does not have any of these disadvantages.

The lactic acid is buffered with its sodium, potassium, and or ammonium salt. In view of effectiveness and price, a buffer system comprising lactic acid and ammonium lactate is preferred. Such systems do not longer require the presence of zinc sulfate, which is further advantage of the present method.

The invention can be performed in the pH range 5.1 to 6.5, but at the higher pH values the derusting process is much slower. For that reason it is preferred to perform the process at a pH between 5.1 and 5.7. The method can be used at ambient temperature but when more quicker removal of rust is required the temperature of the aqueous acid solution may be raised to 70 ⁰C, and if necessary to even higher temperatures until the boiling point of water. The method of the invention is of particular interest for plant cooling systems through which the aqueous acid solution is pumped for usually 4 to 12 hours. When higher temperatures are used the circulation time can be shortened, which is favorable for shortening the shut down time.

The invention is further illustrated by the following examples, which show the benefits of this invention. Materials

• 50% (w/w) hydrolyzed L (+) -lactic acid (Prepared from PURAC HS 90, lot no. 2040800104)

• NaOH pellets, 98%

• 25% (w/w) ammonia • citric acid

• Steel (already partly corroded) ASTM steel panels (101.5 X 150 mm)

• Demineralized tap water

• Acetone • Hard water (50 "German hardness or °dH)

Six steel ASTM panels, which were already rusted, were brushed in order to remove the loose rust particles. After the panels were brushed, they were weighed and photographed. After the panels were photographed, they were placed on a construction wherein on a horizontal bar steel wires having the same length were connected. At the end of every steel wire, a paperclip was placed. The paperclip was used as a locking mechanism for the panel. By this way the panels could hang freely into the test solution. At t = 0 hours the panels were partly submerged into a stirred 5% or 10 % (w/w) sodium lactate solution at different concentration and temperatures. The glass beakers, containing the partly submerged panels, were covered with aluminum foil. This simulates a closed system in the daily practice. At certain time intervals (see results) the panels were lifted out of the test solutions, immediately rinsed with demi-water (to remove the acid) , rinsed with acetone, dried with an air hose, weighed, and finally photographed. At every time interval the time was stopped, until the panels were partly submerged in the test solutions again. After 48 hours the test was stopped.

Ammonium lactate solution was prepared from commercially available ammonium lactate to obtain a 10.0% (w/w) ammonium lactate solution. This concentration corresponds to a calculated concentration of lactic acid of 8.4% The solution was than brought to pH 5.7 by addition of 0.7% sodium hydroxide . As comparison (di) ammonium citrate was prepared from citric acid as follows. The weight in amount of citric acid was based on the theoretically starting amount of L (+) -lactic acid in the used ammonium lactate solution. This is 8.4 % (w/w) acid. The citric acid was partly neutralized by adding 6.8% of ammonia, 25% to give pH 5.7. As a result, the calculated concentration of ammonium citrate in this solution was 10% as well .

Example 1 The derusting performance of sodium lactate and ammonium lactate was compared with ammonium citrate at pH 5.1 and pH 5.7. 10% (w/w) solutions, pH 5.7, of respectively ammonium lactate (NH₄L) and sodium lactate (NaL), and 8.4% (w/w) solution, pH 5.7, of NH₄L and ammonium citrate (NH₄C) were prepared in hard water (50 °dH) . These solutions were tested for their derusting performance at 50 ⁰C. The test was repeated with 5% (w/w) NH₄L and NaL solutions at pH 5.1. Results are given in Tables 1. The corrosion as function of the pH was also determined and the results are depicted in Table 2. Table 1 (derusting)

* weight difference of panels after 2 hours (g)

Table 1 shows that both sodium lactate and ammonium lactate are effective in derusting steel panels, the latter being more effective than sodium lactate. Ammonium citrate is not effective at this pH. The prior art pH conditions (pH 3-5) lead to substantial more corrosion than the instant invention operating at higher pH. This is demonstrated by the experiments of Example 2.

Example 2

Two solutions of sodium lactate (NaL) at pH 3 and pH 5.7 were determined for their corrosion on two types of steel coupons (C-15 and C-1010) . These types of steel are considered as standard types of steel. Two coupons of each type of steel were (water-free) abraded with grit paper P 220, then with P 400 and acetone. The coupons were then submerged in the test solutions of 5% (w/w) NaL at pH 3 and pH 5.7. The samples were placed in a stove at 50 ⁰C for 56 hours. After certain time intervals the coupons were rinsed with water and acetone. After the coupons were dried, the coupons were photographed and weighed (back) . After 56 hours the test was stopped. The results are depicted in Table 2.

Table 2 (corrosion)

Table 2 shows that the pH conditions (pH 3-5) according to the prior art lead to substantial more corrosion than the instant invention operating at higher pH.

Claims

1. A method for derusting a metallic surface by bringing the surface in contact with an aqueous solution of a buffer having a pH between 5.1 and 6.5, wherein the buffer comprises lactic acid and the sodium, potassium and/or ammonium salt of lactic acid.

2. The method according to claim 1 wherein the buffer is a mixture of lactic acid and ammonium lactate.

3. The method according to claims 1-3 wherein the pH of the buffer is between 5.1 and 5.7.

4. The method according to claims 1-3 wherein the aqueous solution of the buffer is pumped through a system comprising metallic surfaces.

5. The method according to claims 1-4 wherein the metallic surface is steel.

6. The method according to claims 1-5 wherein the aqueous solution has a temperature from ambient temperature to 60 °C.

7. The method according to claims 1-6 for use in derusting metallic parts of cooling system.